A Free, Downloadable Booklet (if you dare)

The City of David, the narrow spur of land extending southward from the Haram al-Sharif (Temple Mount), represents — if the experts are correct — the original settled core of ancient Jerusalem, and for that reason it is hugely important to the disciplines of historical geography and archaeology, among others. The City of David is also part of a larger, living community known as Silwan, populated by many Palestinian Arabs and a few Jews and lying in the part of Jerusalem unilaterally “annexed” by the State of Israel after the 1967 war. Not surprisingly perhaps, with the extensive archaeological projects undertaken in recent years, and the development of a very popular and busy “national park” (in quotes for a reason!), the area has emerged as a flash point for a number of issues central to the ongoing struggle over Jerusalem. And the archaeology, and the way it has been carried out, is not tangential to all this — it is central.

In response, a Jerusalem NGO was formed which goes by the name “Emek Shaveh” (a biblical place-name found in Gen. 14:17), a group composed of Israeli archaeologists, local Silwan residents and others. They have attempted for the past few years to open some of these issues up to public scrutiny and public discourse, in the hopes of finding just, rational solutions for this conflicted neighborhood. For one thing, they operate their own visitors’ information center on Ir David Street. They also conduct a free walking tour that highlights not only the fascinating achaeology but also the neigborhood’s troubling social, legal and political crosscurrents (register here). I would encourage you to seek out these two resources when you are in Jerusalem, again — if you dare. The Emek Shaveh bunch, frankly, are the “small group of vocal protestors” whose complaints Hershel Shanks so blithely dismisses in his current editorial in BAR (which I will not deconstruct today — maybe another time).

One of the principals of the organization is archaeologist Dr. Rafi Greenberg of Tel Aviv University, who has spoken out repeatedly over the years on what he sees as problematic aspects (especially political) of Israeli archaeology. For example, here is a 2006 interview focusing on Israeli practices in the Occupied Palestinian Territories over the last 40-plus years. More recently, here is his opinion piece which appeared in Haaretz (October 2009) dealing with the troubling aspects, as he sees them, of the archaeological work currently being carried out in Jerusalem.

In any event, the Emek Shaveh group has just published a free, informative booklet which presents, in an organized way, their “take” on what is going on in Silwan/the City of David today. Their web-site says:

After almost a year of work, we have published the booklet “Archaeology in the Shadow of the Conflict: The Mound of Ancient Jerusalem (City of David) in Silwan”. This publication discusses the responsibility of the archaeologist in a conflict zone, the relations of local residents to the scientific research, and the political impact of archaeology on the conflict. This is the first ever attempt to show the role of Archaeology in the Israeli – Palestinian conflict, and to propose an alternative to the way archaeology is being practiced, presented and accepted by the general public. The excavation site “City of David” and the Palestinian town of Silwan on the outskirts of East Jerusalem are used as a test case for those issues. But the core of the issues discussed in the booklet is applicable to many cases of archaeology in conflict zones, in a variety of places and sites.

You are welcome to download your copy from their web site (where there are many other resources as well), or you can order a printed copy in Hebrew, English or Arabic. (Note: The downloadable version, perhaps to keep the file-size managable, has low-resolution graphics; some of these maps, etc. can probably be found elsewhere on the site, though.)

The booklet, I think, will either open your eyes to issues you had never considered before — or it will give you heartburn, or maybe a bit of both! But, in my opinion, these are voices worth listening to.

This entry was posted in City of David, Israel-Palestine Scene, Issues in Archaeology, Jerusalem Antiquities, Resources, VIDEOS and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to A Free, Downloadable Booklet (if you dare)

  1. Todd Bolen says:

    Tom – a few things I can say here, but I’ll limit myself to just one. In your first sentence you say “if the experts are correct.” By this phrase, are you intending to suggest that the experts may not be correct? If not, why do you say this? To me, a phrase like that symbolizes so much of what is wrong about the other side – a basic unwillingness to recognize facts that are well established. Do you think the presence of Hebrew seals, monumental Iron Age architecture, and a water tunnel with a Hebrew inscription attests to the fact that this was the heart of biblical Jerusalem? If so, let’s agree on that. That doesn’t demand that all the Arabs have to move out of the area, but when the Arab side denies basic realities (and would love to keep denying them by forbidding excavation, as they do on the Temple Mount), then it’s no wonder that the Arab side has minimal support from people in the U.S.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s